17
Mar
13

REVIEW: JBL Play UP portable NFC BT Speaker

WP_000015Thanks to the Nokia Connects team we have received a trial JBL Play Up which is the first speaker incarnation from their partnership with Nokia for audio accessory design. For those of you who have been Nokia followers for a few years the JBL Play Up is a development of the Nokia 360 portable BT (Bluetooth) speaker with a modernised Lumia styling and JBL audio internals.

As a long time user of both the Nokia and JBL product catalogue. The simplest comparison is audio quality of the new JBL Play Up vs that of the older JBL On-Stage (from 2005) and JBL On-Stage micro (from c.2007).

In The Box

WP_000021

The JBL Play Up speaker is supplied with a tight fitting black neoprene pouch with cyan internal accenting, A Nokia BL-5J battery, a micro-USB to USB cable and USB mains plug. In addition to this, removing the bottom cover provides access to a 1m audio cable.

WP_000031

In comparison the JBL On-Stage micro speaker was supplied with a black fabric zip-up pouch with slots for all accessories, including a mains cable/plug, audio cable, a remote control and, as it is an iPod accessory, a number of iPod dock connections. No batteries were provided as the JBL On-Stage micro is powered from mains or four AAA batteries.

Dimensions & Weight

WP_000026

When it come to weight, the older JBL On-Stage Micro (375g) wins again as it is less than half the weight of the JBL Play Up (760g) which aligns to to the volume difference.

WP_000032

For this comparison I will stick with the JBL On-Stage Micro and JBL Play Up. The JBL Play Up’s (128mm height and 118mm diameter (445cm³ )) portability is based around it’s small size, although the JBL On-Stage Micro (38mm height and 148 mm diameter (208cm³ )) packs more easily as it is less than 30% of the height and 50% of the volume.

Appearance

WP_000027

The JBL Play Up speaker is available in a number of colours, with the one I am testing being stealth-like, matte black. The only issue I have with the appearance of the JBL Play Up speaker is the matte finish on the speaker body shows fingerprints extremely easily. This can be avoided by keeping the speaker in it’s black neoprene pouch, except for the fact that the power button can not be easily operated, charging is not possible and low end sound quality is slightly hindered in the pouch.

The JBL On-stage micro came in glossy white, surprisingly enough, as it is an iPod accessory.

Power

Moving on to power, the JBL Play Up is quoted as capable of up to 10hrs, compared with the original claim of 24hrs for the JBL On-Stage micro. The time a gadget operates for comes down to two factors: the amount of power under the hood, and how power hungry it is.

WP_000024

Power Pack: The JBL Play Up comes with a Nokia BL-5J 1430mAh 3.7V rechargeable battery, whereas the JBL On-Stage Mini runs of mains, or four AAA batteries (700mAh each for standard rechargeable batteries).

WP_000025

Power Consumption: Based on the functionality of the two devices, there is no surprise that the JBL On-Stage Micro lasts longer as its only connectivity is via a standard 3.5mm stereo mini-jack socket, whereas the JBL Play Up incorporates Bluetooth and NFC connectivity, which is known to cause more power drain than a wired connection.

WP_000035

Re-charging is easy on the JBL Play Up speaker as it uses a standard mini-USB using the high-speed USB 2.0 standard and an included USB to mini-USB cable enable mains of PC based power. The JBL On-Stage Mini does not permit in-device recharging of the four AAA batteries, but having no available charging source is not an issue as normal non-rechargeable batteries can be used. 

Connectivity

WP_000023

Connectivity is where the JBL Play Up speaker takes the lead with wired (1m 3.5mm audio jack-to-jack cable included) and wireless (Bluetooth 2.1 +EDR) which is eased by NFC ( Near Field Communication) to speed up connection and disconnection.

WP_000034

As the JBL On-Stage micro is aimed at the iPod generation, it incorporates an iPod dock with mains socket, separate audio in and out connections and a USB mini connection for iPod – PC synchronisation at the rear. For this review I am only really interested in the mains and audio in connections.

Audio

The JBL Play Up speaker contains 1.75″ 3-watt full range drivers with a maximum output of 89dB at 0.5m and an audio range of  85Hz – 22kHz (-6db). I would love to provide more stats, but they appear to be few and far between.

In comparison, the JBL On-Stage Mini audio quality is built on the two 15-watt aluminium-domed Odyssey transducers and one 30-watt proprietary "slipstream" port architecture for improved bass response providing an audio range of 70Hz – 20kHz.

Unluckily the specifications available for both devices aren’t as aligned as I had hoped, so it’s time to move on to the physical test.

Physical Sound Test

For the test I used a number of different styles of music including:

  • “Read All About It (Pt.III)” by Emeli Sande from “Our Version of Events”
  • “Insomnia” by Faithless from “Faithless Forever: The Greatest Hits”
  • “Call Me When Your Sober” by Evanscence from “The Open Door”
  • “Karmacoma” by Massive Attack from “Protection”
  • “Dirt Off Your Shoulder/Lying From You” by Linkin Park & Jay-Z from “ Collision Course”

These tracks were selected to test out the full range of audio from each speaker.

The sound quality from both speakers is impressive for their size and portability, with the JBL Play Up proving a very rich, full, sound from high end treble to low end bass, and the bass is where the JBL Play Up wins hands down over the JBL On-Stage micro.

In comparison the JBL On-Stage micro sound provides a more open sound than the JBL Play Up within it’s capable range, although it is left sounding small and tinny when up against the JBL Play Up.

During testing, the JBL Play Up speaker performance was not hindered at any point by mobile phone interference, unlike the JBL On-Stage and most other speakers I have experienced.

Pricing

The current price mark for the JBL Play Up is £128.84 at Amazon UK with it’s RRP being £144.99.

Although the JBL On-Stage micro has moved on since 2005, the latest incarnation, JBL On-Stage micro III is £38.00 in white or £75.55 in black, again at Amazon UK, although the RRP is at £99.99.

Conclusions

Although many of the on-paper specification comparisons above imply that the battle may be a close one, with the possibility of the JBL On-Stage micro being the victor, this is far from the end result.

The JBL Play Up wins hands down with wireless connectivity, NFC support and richer sound extending fully into the bass spectrum all be it a little enclosed when compared with the JBL On-Stage micro.

The other major advantage for the JBL Play Up is it’s lack of mobile interference to the audio experience.

The main question you have to ask yourself is how much do you love your music and how much money do you have to spend.

Score

Build Quality

starstarstarstarstar

Functional Performance

starstarstarstarstar-not

Aesthetics

starstarstarstarstar-not

Value for Money

starstarstarstar-notstar-not


3 Responses to “REVIEW: JBL Play UP portable NFC BT Speaker”


  1. 1 Hassan
    September 1, 2013 at 10:17 am

    Nice and detailed review. This is one of the few reviews which mentions the detailed specs of the speaker such as the range. A friend of mine just gave me his because he got it for free but does not have any use for it. Build quality is certainly better than the play 360 speaker, and the sound is fuller and less hollow. Although it is nowhere near as impressive as the Bose SoundLink which costs three time as much, it is competent enough to full a room with decent sound.

    Sound is best enjoyed when directed at you, however in the lounge Im not always sitting in the same spot so the omni directional sound offers good flexibility. Annoyances I have experienced during my 4 hours of ownership is latency over bluetooth and the necessity to tweak the sound using an EQ to get the right balance between the lows, mids and highs.

  2. May 20, 2014 at 11:35 am

    Hi, very interesting post thanks for sharing. Can I contact your through your email. Thanks!

    Randy
    randydavis387 at gmail.com


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


mbrett

Twitter Updates


%d bloggers like this: